Thursday, February 6, 2025
Monday, February 3, 2025
Immigration Reform Law Institute: IRLI Defends President Trump’s Order on Birthright Citizenship
Shows court controlling Supreme Court precedent dooms challenge |
WASHINGTON—Today, the Immigration Reform Law Institute (IRLI) filed an important brief in Maryland federal district court in a case on birthright citizenship. Plaintiffs, a group of organizations with illegal alien members, claim that President Trump's executive order restricting birthright citizenship is unconstitutional, and that children of illegal aliens are guaranteed citizenship in the Fourteenth Amendment.
The Citizenship Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment provides that persons born in the United States while "subject to the jurisdiction" of the United States are citizens. The question then becomes whether illegal aliens—and others present in the United States, such as tourists—are subject to the jurisdiction of the United States.
To answer that question, IRLI analyzes a controlling Supreme Court case, United States v. Wong Kim Ark, decided in 1898. Wong Kim Ark was born in San Francisco to Chinese parents legally residing there. He later returned with his parents to China. Denied readmittance, Wong Kim Ark argued before the Supreme Court that the Fourteenth Amendment made him a citizen of the United States at his birth.
The Supreme Court agreed, holding that, because—and only because—his parents were legally residing in the United States when he was born here, he was a citizen at birth under the Fourteenth Amendment. The holding of this case is widely misread as conferring citizenship at birth under the Fourteenth Amendment on all persons whatsoever born in the United States (with the narrow exceptions of children of diplomats, members of an invading force, or Indians born in the allegiance of a tribe). IRLI shows in its brief that this reading is wrong; the Court clearly excluded the children of illegal aliens and non-U.S. residents from constitutional birthright citizenship:
Chinese persons, born out of the United States, remaining subjects of the Emperor of China, and not having become citizens of the United States, are entitled to the protection of and owe allegiance to the United States, so long as they are permitted by the United States to reside here; and are "subject to the jurisdiction thereof."
In other words, the Supreme Court has clearly held that, to be a citizen at birth under the Fourteenth Amendment, one must be born in the United States to a parent who, at the time, resided with permission in the United States. This rule happens to exclude the children of both illegal aliens (who do not have permission to be in the country) and tourists (who do not "reside" here) from constitutional birthright citizenship.
Thus, the plaintiffs' claim that President Trump's order is unconstitutional on its face—that is, would have no valid application in any situation—is wrong: the order correctly denies birthright citizenship to all children of illegal aliens, tourists, and others who do not reside with permission in the United States.
"Amazingly, the broad but reasonable holding of Wong Kim Ark—excluding the children of non-residents and illegal aliens from citizenship at birth under the Constitution—has been ignored or misstated for 127 years," said Dale L. Wilcox, executive director and general counsel of IRLI. "Meanwhile, millions, including the children of so-called 'birth tourists,' have been assumed to be citizens even though the Supreme Court has held they are not. In America, neither foreigners with no connection to this country nor those here against the will of the nation should get to decide who shall be American citizens. President Trump's order stops that going forward, and we hope the court recognizes its validity under the Constitution."
The case is Casa, Inc. v. Trump, No. 8:25-cv-00201 (D. Md.). |
Saturday, February 1, 2025
Zehr for Virginia: Session 2025 Update
The halfway point of the 2025 General Assembly Session is almost here. The activity around Capitol Square has ramped into overdrive as we race toward Crossover, the point at which each chamber can only take up the other chamber's bills. And while I'm disappointed with the overall outcome from our Democratic majority, I am proud of the successes we've had. Like most of my Republican colleagues, several of my bills were not even given a hearing and most that were heard, were dismissed. One of those would have required that ballot drop boxes be monitored by video. I pointed out to the Democrat-controlled committee hearing the bill, that since moving to 45 days of voting, there is a lot of room for mischief and having the boxes monitored by video would boost confidence. If we're going to the expense of a 45-day voting season, let's at least put video monitoring in place to make the drop boxes more secure. Another of my bills, which wasn't even docketed, calls for a 20-year statute of limitations for victims of sex-disguising ("trans-gender") procedures to sue their medical provider. The ethics of having children make decisions that could permanently alter their physical constitution is questionable at best and those who manipulate vulnerable children in this way should be held accountable.
|
|
|
|
Virginia Education Opportunity Alliance: Microschooling 101: Learn what it takes to start your own microschool?
|
| ||
|
Thursday, January 30, 2025
Steve Haner, Thomas Jefferson Institute:The Jefferson Journal: Senate Democrats Threatening $633 Tax Hike on Millions of Virginians
|
|
Tuesday, January 21, 2025
Federation for American Immigration Reform
FAIR: Passage of the Laken Riley Act is Just the First Step in
Restoring Common Sense to Our Immigration Policies
The following statement was issued by Dan Stein, president of the Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR) in response to passage of the Laken Riley Act in the Senate.
(Washington, D.C., January 20, 2025) "Today, the U.S. Senate took the long overdue step of passing the Laken Riley Act. FAIR congratulates Senate Majority Leader John Thune for bringing this bill to the floor of the chamber and putting every member of the Senate on record as supporting or opposing the detention and removal of illegal aliens who commit crimes in this country.
"Passage of the Laken Riley Act is a promising first step in reversing the rampant illegal immigration that the nation has endured over the past four years. There is still much more to be done to secure our borders, alleviate the enormous fiscal burdens being borne by American taxpayers and ensure that no future administration will be able to abuse its authority to subvert our immigration laws.
"In the coming weeks and months, Congress must act swiftly to pass an updated version of H.R. 2, a bill that includes real changes that end catch-and-release, reform our asylum system, stop parole abuse, and prevent future administrations from ignoring their duties to enforce our immigration laws. Congress must also use the reconciliation process to fully fund construction of the border wall and provide the manpower and other resources needed to detain and remove illegal aliens from our country.
"Today's Senate vote is a small measure of comfort to Laken Riley's family and the families of countless others who have been victimized by illegal aliens who were allowed to roam freely in our country. But it is just the start of a long list of reforms that are needed to ensure that our immigration system serves and protects the security and interests of the American people."
Federation for American Immigration Reform
FAIR Congratulates Donald Trump on Being Sworn In as Our 47th President
Carrying Out His Mandate to End Illegal Immigration and Reforming Our
Immigration Policies Begins Today
The following statement was issued by Dan Stein, president of the Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR), on the Inauguration of President Donald Trump and Vice President JD Vance:
(Washington, D.C., January 20, 2025) "Open borders and unprecedented illegal immigration is a key reason why American voters returned President Trump to the White House and handed control of both chambers of Congress to Republicans. The president and the Republican-led Congress have a clear mandate to restore control of our borders, begin removing illegal aliens from our country and erect guard rails to prevent any future administration from running roughshod over our immigration laws the way the Biden-Harris administration did.
"There is no time to waste. Realistically, much of that work must be accomplished in the next six months. The Trump-Vance administration should take immediate steps to restart construction of the border wall and to reestablish effective policies that discourage illegal immigration, such as ending mass catch-and-release policies and reinstating Remain in Mexico, which proved effective in deterring illegal immigration during Mr. Trump's first term.
"Halting continued large-scale immigration is only the first step. As he takes office today, President Trump has broad public support for his promise to remove millions of illegal aliens in this country, beginning with criminals, people who have been issued final orders of removal and the millions more who entered our country during the previous administration.
"We also call upon the Trump-Vance administration to terminate the illegal parole programs put in place by its predecessor, halt the abuse of our asylum process and reform legal settlements that have encouraged the arrival of unaccompanied children and even facilitated human trafficking.
"Some of these goals can be accomplished through the upcoming reconciliation process. Other changes, such as enacting a comprehensive border security bill like H.R. 2, that was passed by the House in 2023 but blocked in the Democratic-controlled Senate, are also within reach with support of the president and swift action from Speaker Mike Johnson and Senate Majority Leader John Thune.
"FAIR looks forward to working with the new administration and congressional leaders to carry out the broad mandate the voters handed them in November. That work begins today."
Thomas D. Klingenstein
|
|
|
Sunday, January 12, 2025
Tuesday, January 7, 2025
Thomas D. Klingenstein: MAGA’s Best Leaders Will Be Unexpected
|
|
|
The Family Foundation: These Students Need YOUR VOICE at the State Capitol!
|
|
|
|
|
Sunday, January 5, 2025
Derrick Max: Your January 5, 2025 First Sunday Summary of the Year: Speaker Johnson, New Laws, Car Inspections and Car Taxes, Flag over Korea, Gambling, Energy, Governor's race...and more. Enjoy!
|
|
|
|
|