Monday, March 11, 2024

Derrick Max, Thomas Jefferson Institute for Public Policy: Your March 10, 2024 Sunday Summary...Primary, SOTU, Endorsements, Vetoes, B2B Taxes, Teacher Pay, Budgets, Dead Whales, Stadiums and more....

"The veto power is a critical tool for maintaining the balance of power and ensuring that legislation aligns with the best interests of all Virginians. As governor, I will not hesitate to use this authority to protect the rights and well-being of our citizens."

L. Douglas Wilder

It has been a busy week in Richmond, with the passage of the budget conference report, the discharge of 84 bills sent to the Governor on a seven-day deadline, and the continued accumulation of hundreds of other extremely partisan bills sent to the Governor for his consideration over the next few weeks.


With hundreds of extremely partisan bills still on the Governor's desk, most passing on straight party-line votes, the question becomes: will Gov. Youngkin break the Virginia veto record? Gov. McAuliffe vetoed 49 bills passed by Republican majorities in both chambers in 2017 and a whopping 120 bills during his full term. Northam managed to veto 54 bills over the two years he faced Republican majorities in both chambers. 


VETO CONTEST FOR $5 BLACK RIFLE COFFEE GIFT CARD


Two winners will be chosen at random from those that choose the correct answer -- good luck!

Of the bills sent to Governor Youngkin during the 2024 General Assembly, he will veto:
Less than 20 bills
between 21 and 49 bills
between 50 and 75 bills
between 76 and 100 bills
over 100 bills



1.) Virginia's primary went as expected, with Biden winning 89 percent of Democrats and Trump winning 63 percent of Republicans. Haley took in 35 percent by winning the urban and suburban vote in places like Northern Virginia, Richmond, and Charlottesville (a great map of results can be found on VPAP's site here). Dwayne Yancey at Cardinal News (here) believes that while the results are good for both candidates, they also expose their weaknesses. Biden's results showed a lack of enthusiasm and Trump's results showed a still divided party and trouble with suburban voters. Some of the results may be skewed due to cross-over votes for Haley from Democrats -- lowering Biden's turnout and artificially lowering Trump's margin of victory in those suburban areas.


2.) Governor Youngkin and Jason Miyares endorsed former President Trump after his Super Tuesday victory (here).


3.) Biden used his State of the Union speech to build enthusiasm in his base by pushing for every extreme left-of-center policy idea imaginable. He also managed to look sentient and capable (although the "get off my lawn" cadence and volume were odd). The Republican response by Senator Katie Britt (R-AL) was decent in content but is being widely panned for its theatrics and kitchen table setting. Senator Britt is a rising star, let's hope this doesn't set her back. 


4.) In advance of the Governor's Friday deadline to act on multiple bills, the Thomas Jefferson Institute sent a letter urging him to veto seven troubling bills and to strike two bad budget items. See our letter below:


5.) Governor Youngkin took action on 84 bills late Friday night, signing 64 bills with broad bipartisan support into law, amending 12 bills, and vetoing 8 (Read Gov. Youngkin's explanations here). Among the bills signed were a bill to end legacy college admissions and a bill to ensure same-sex marriage remains legal (here). Among the bills vetoed were bills to return Virginia to the ERIC voter rolls, to limit the removal of offensive books from schools, and to force the doubling of crews on freight trains -- a bill the Thomas Jefferson Institute opposed in the Richmond Times Dispatch for being a union-boosting bill with no evidence it would improve safety (here).  Thanks for the veto, Governor!


6.) Gov. Youngkin's most creative amendment was to edit a bill requiring schools to notify parents of their responsibility to keep guns locked up and safe, into a bill to require schools to send parents a list of all their rights and responsibilities, adding the right to be notified of sexually explicit materials in school, the right to express disagreement with school and school board policies, and the right to be protected from drugs, exploitation and abuse while at school. Well played, Governor!


7.) The largest and most economically damaging tax increase of the 2024 session is the expansion of the sales and use tax to digital products and services, including purchases made by businesses. Business-to-business transactions are usually exempt from the sales tax, so this is a major policy change that will cost Virginia businesses an additional $2 billion in taxes. Thomas Jefferson Institute Senior Fellow Steve Haner discusses the danger of this tax (here).  


8.) With massive increases in teacher salaries included in the passed budget agreement, Thomas Jefferson Institute's Chris Braunlich argued last week that reform needs to be put ahead of blanket pay increases (here) and our Nancy Almasi wrote that while teacher resignations are often behind the call for higher pay, studies show that most teachers are leaving teaching for reasons unrelated to pay -- including student behavior, poor leadership, workload and lack of support (here).


9.) Governor Youngkin said in a Friday press conference that the budget rewrite in the passed Conference Report includes a $2.5 billion tax hike that will hit low and moderate-income Virginians the most (here). He rightly called this a "backwards budget" that would undo a lot of the gains Virginia has made over the last two years.


10.) Governor Youngkin expressed disappointment in the failure to include his stadium proposal in the budget despite bipartisan support. An internal text by Alexandria Mayor Justin Wilson disclosed this week through a FOIA request noted that the plan was to be funded by "taxing the crap" out of users (here). Jeff Schapiro wrote an insightful article on the failure to sell this stadium in Richmond generally and to Sen. Lucas specifically (here). Our hope is that Governor Youngkin finds a way to build the stadium in Potomac Yard without state funding or massive state bond guarantees.


11.) Dominion's Coastal Virginia Offshore Wind Project is getting complaints from Virginia Beach residents who are describing earthquake-like noises, cracks in walls, and other nuisances from the construction (here). Whales would be joining in on the complaints, but as our Steve Haner noted in Bacon's Rebellion (here) they are washing ashore dead. Imagine how quickly the construction of a new oil drilling platform would be halted if whales were dying at the rate they are in the vicinity of this wind project… 


12.) Senator Perry's Recovery School proposal for drug-addicted students was forwarded to next year's session, essentially killing it for now (here). 


13.) Liberty University agreed to pay an unprecedented $14 million fine for its failure to disclose campus crime information as required by the Clery Act (here). Liberty has expressed concern about selective and unfair treatment in this process -- a reasonable concern considering the next largest Clery Act fines ever issued were only $4.5 million paid by Michigan State for its failures in the handling of Dr. Larry Nassar in the case of his sexual abuse of elite gymnasts and other female athletes and the $2.4 million fine against Penn State for its failures in the handling of the child sexual abuse cases against football coach Jerry Sandusky. 

 

14.) Coach Joe Gibbs' Youth for Tomorrow -- a school for at-risk children in Bristow, cashed in on the data center boom by selling 70 of its acres to Stack Infrastructure for $81.3 million (here). That's a touchdown for the school and the youth they serve!